Our Tips & Tricks

Make a Magic Eraser Copycat on a Budget

May 25, 2024

Make a Magic Eraser Copycat on a Budget

The Frustration of Expensive Cleaning Tools

As a busy parent, I know all too well the struggle of keeping a clean home. Whenever a stubborn stain or grimy surface crops up, I usually reach for a trusty Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. These little white rectangles are absolute workhorses, scrubbing away grime and restoring surfaces to their former glory. But there’s one major downside – the price tag.

Those four-packs of Magic Erasers can really add up, especially if you’re a cleaning fanatic like me. I once went through an entire pack in a single afternoon, tackling everything from the stovetop to the bathroom tiles. By the time I was done, my wallet was considerably lighter, and I couldn’t help but wonder if there was a more budget-friendly alternative.

The Magic Ingredient: Melamine Foam

As it turns out, the secret to those cleaning superpowers lies in the material used to make Magic Erasers – melamine foam. This unique type of foam has a microstructure that’s almost as hard as glass, making it an incredibly effective abrasive. As CNET explains, the open-cell structure of melamine foam “pulls dirt into the open cells, helping to pull it away from the surface you’re cleaning.”

So, if the magic is in the melamine, why pay a premium for the Mr. Clean brand? As it turns out, you don’t have to. All you need to do is source the raw material and make your own custom cleaning pads.

DIY Magic Erasers on a Dime

After some digging, I discovered that you can find large sheets or bulk packs of melamine foam online for a fraction of the cost of pre-made Magic Erasers. BuzzFeed reports that you can snag a 20-pack of generic melamine sponges on Amazon for just $8.95 – that’s about 45 cents per sponge, compared to the $1 (or more) you’d pay for a single Magic Eraser.

All you have to do is cut the melamine foam into your desired shape and size, then customize it with your own cleaning solution. CNET suggests a simple mixture of borax and baking soda, which you can spritz onto the sponge or apply directly.

I decided to give this DIY approach a try, and the results were honestly mind-blowing. I managed to whip up a whole batch of homemade Magic Erasers for just a few bucks, and they worked just as well as the store-bought version. In fact, I’d argue they’re even more effective, since I can customize the size and shape to tackle specific cleaning challenges around my home.

Putting the DIY Erasers to the Test

To put my homemade magic erasers to the test, I started with a real doozy – the aftermath of a particularly cheesy mac and cheese incident on my stovetop. Just as BuzzFeed reported, the generic melamine sponge I’d made held up remarkably well, scrubbing away the crusted-on cheese without crumbling to pieces.

Next, I tackled a pesky scuff mark on the wall near my desk chair. I pitted my DIY eraser against the store-bought version, and they both performed admirably, completely removing the gunk without any damage to the paint. I’m already envisioning a spotless apartment when I move out, and those security deposit dollars coming right back to me.

Finally, I decided to see how the homemade erasers would fare on a tougher job – cleaning the rubber on my well-worn Converse sneakers. Both the DIY and commercial versions did the trick, restoring my shoes to their former glory. The only downside? They both ended up in shreds, so I had to bust out the vacuum afterwards.

Saving Big with Homemade Magic

Overall, I’m thoroughly impressed with how well my DIY magic erasers have held up. Sure, they may not have the fancy ridges or branding of the Mr. Clean version, but they get the job done just as effectively – for a fraction of the cost.

By sourcing the melamine foam in bulk and whipping up my own custom cleaning solution, I’ve managed to create a stash of homemade magic erasers that cost me just pennies per sponge. That’s a far cry from the $1 per eraser I used to shell out, and it means I can clean to my heart’s content without worrying about the price tag.

If you’re tired of the high cost of commercial cleaning products, I highly recommend giving this DIY magic eraser hack a try. Adam Cleaning, the premier cleaning service in Nottingham, UK, swears by this method to keep their clients’ homes spotless on a budget. So grab some melamine foam, get creative with your cleaning solution, and enjoy the satisfaction of a sparkling-clean space – for just a few cents per use.

Continue Reading
New Posts
Why choose us
Professional

With Adam Cleaning, you can expect a team of trained and skilled professionals dedicated to providing top-notch cleaning services. We pride ourselves on our attention to detail and commitment to excellence, ensuring every space we clean is left sparkling.

Guaranteed

Your satisfaction is our top priority. That's why all our services come with a satisfaction guarantee. If you're not completely happy with our work, we'll make it right. That's the Adam Cleaning guarantee.

Total Solution

No matter your cleaning needs, Adam Cleaning is your total solution. From carpet cleaning to ironing services, end of tenancy cleaning to garden cleaning, we offer a wide range of services designed to make your life cleaner, simpler, and more enjoyable.